Jim Bowden Predicts Big Paydays for Phillies Free Agents
Philadelphia, PA — October 28, 2025
The Philadelphia Phillies are entering a pivotal offseason, and former MLB general manager turned analyst Jim Bowden believes the team’s biggest stars are about to cash in. In his annual free-agent contract projections for The Athletic, Bowden predicted lucrative deals for three of Philadelphia’s most important players — Ranger Suárez, Kyle Schwarber, and J.T. Realmuto — setting the stage for what could be one of the most expensive offseasons in franchise history.
Ranger Suárez: 6 Years, $164 Million
Bowden projects left-hander Ranger Suárez will command a six-year, $164 million contract, a figure that would place him among the league’s highest-paid starting pitchers. Suárez, 30, has quietly emerged as one of baseball’s most consistent and clutch arms, thriving in both the regular season and October.
After another standout campaign in 2025 — highlighted by a sub-3.00 ERA and several signature postseason performances — Suárez has established himself as the Phillies’ co-ace alongside Zack Wheeler. His ability to pitch deep into games and neutralize both left- and right-handed hitters has drawn interest across the league.
“Suárez has proven he can handle the pressure of Philadelphia and the postseason spotlight,” Bowden wrote. “His market will be extremely competitive if he reaches free agency.”
For the Phillies, the decision to retain Suárez could hinge on whether they’re willing to commit another nine-figure deal to their rotation — especially with Wheeler already signed long-term.
Kyle Schwarber: 5 Years, $160 Million
Slugger Kyle Schwarber is projected to receive a five-year, $160 million contract, reflecting his continued dominance as one of MLB’s premier power hitters. Since joining Philadelphia in 2022, Schwarber has become the heartbeat of the Phillies’ offense — a player whose towering home runs and fiery leadership have defined the club’s identity.
Despite questions about his batting average and defensive value, Schwarber’s power numbers remain elite. In 2025, he once again topped 40 home runs and ranked among league leaders in walks and OPS. His clubhouse presence and postseason track record only enhance his value.
“Teams value Schwarber for more than his bat,” Bowden noted. “He’s a proven winner and one of the most respected voices in any clubhouse he’s been part of.”
The Phillies, however, face a dilemma: can they afford to re-sign Schwarber while also addressing other needs — particularly pitching depth and bullpen reinforcements?
J.T. Realmuto: 2 Years, $34 Million
At age 35, J.T. Realmuto remains one of the best all-around catchers in baseball. Bowden projects the veteran backstop will earn a two-year, $34 million deal — a contract that balances his declining offensive production with his elite defense, game-calling, and leadership.
Realmuto has been the steady anchor behind the plate since arriving in Philadelphia in 2019. He’s helped guide one of the league’s best rotations and remains a vocal leader on and off the field. Though he’s entering the twilight of his career, his value to a contending team like the Phillies extends far beyond statistics.
If the Phillies do move forward with Realmuto, they may need to begin grooming his successor — possibly from within their farm system — while maintaining his veteran presence for another postseason run.
Financial Implications and Phillies Outlook
Should Bowden’s projections hold true, the Phillies could be looking at over $350 million in potential contracts just to retain these three players. That would push the club’s payroll well beyond the competitive balance tax threshold — a significant financial commitment, even for a big-market team.
President of Baseball Operations Dave Dombrowski has never been shy about spending to win, but this offseason could test the organization’s limits. Philadelphia’s core, led by Bryce Harper, Trea Turner, and Zack Wheeler, remains in its prime, and ownership may be willing to spend aggressively to keep the championship window open.
Still, difficult decisions loom. The front office must weigh long-term financial flexibility against the desire to maintain a veteran-laden roster built to win now.
What’s Next
Negotiations with free agents typically heat up after the World Series, and the Phillies’ moves in November and December will reveal how closely Bowden’s predictions align with reality. Whether or not all three players return, Philadelphia’s 2025-26 offseason is shaping up to be one of the most consequential in recent franchise history.
“This is a team built to win championships,” Bowden concluded. “The question is how far ownership is willing to go to keep that core together.”
About the Author
