Braves Showing Questionable Optimism About Reynaldo López’s Future
Lost amid the many struggles of the Atlanta Braves this season is how the team stumbled early when Reynaldo López underwent shoulder surgery. After a strong first year back in the rotation—despite minor injuries—the Braves had counted on him to anchor their pitching staff. His injury, however, was one of the first dominoes that ultimately led to Atlanta missing the playoffs for the first time since 2017.
López’s durability has long been a concern. He was originally shifted to the bullpen earlier in his career because of questions about whether his body could handle a starter’s workload. Despite that history, the Braves appear determined to keep him in the rotation. Team president Alex Anthopoulos told The Athletic that López’s ability to both start and relieve was a key factor in signing him, and the organization still views him as a starter.
The debate isn’t about López’s effectiveness—it’s about his health. If he remains in the rotation and breaks down again, the Braves risk losing him entirely. After missing time late in 2024 and most of 2025, there’s mounting evidence that his body isn’t built to withstand a starter’s innings.
A shift back to the bullpen could provide Atlanta with another valuable, multi-inning relief weapon, and would reduce the risk of losing him for long stretches. While López himself may not favor such a move, it may prove to be the safer and more sustainable option for both the player and the team.
About the Author
