September 16, 2025
Cincinnati Reds news
Cincinnati, OH – The Cincinnati Reds’ playoff hopes remain on the line, but franchise icon Johnny Bench has sparked a conversation that few expected. The Hall of Fame catcher and Reds legend spoke candidly this week about young star Elly De La Cruz, suggesting that the electrifying shortstop may need time away from the starting lineup.
Bench, who knows the pressures of carrying a franchise, outlined three key reasons why he believes the Reds should consider benching De La Cruz in the coming games:
1. Offensive Struggles
Bench pointed to De La Cruz’s drop-off at the plate since the All-Star break. With a batting average hovering in the low .220s and limited power production in recent weeks, the 23-year-old has not provided the spark the team has needed during a crucial stretch. “Sometimes, stepping back is the best way to reset your swing and your mind,” Bench noted.
2. Defensive Concerns
Despite his athleticism, De La Cruz has led the majors in errors this season. Bench emphasized that the Reds can’t afford costly mistakes in tight September games. “Defense wins ballgames too. Taking pressure off him now might help him return stronger and sharper,” he said.
3. Mental and Physical Fatigue
Having started nearly every game this year, De La Cruz may be wearing down. Bench highlighted the importance of rest for a young player still adjusting to the grind of a 162-game season. “He’s played almost nonstop. Sometimes the best thing for a young player is a mental break. It’s not punishment—it’s protection,” Bench explained.
While the suggestion stirred debate among Reds fans, many acknowledged that Bench’s words carry weight. A product of the legendary “Big Red Machine,” the Hall of Famer understands the fine balance between talent, development, and results.
Whether manager Terry Francona will follow Bench’s advice remains to be seen. For now, Reds fans are left weighing a difficult question: is sitting De La Cruz the best way to get him back to being the dynamic star they know he can be?
About the Author
