DeWitt Jr. Addresses Oli Marmol’s Mistakes That Contributed to Cardinals’ Elimination
St. Louis, MO – St. Louis Cardinals chairman Bill DeWitt Jr. has spoken publicly for the first time since the team’s disappointing playoff elimination, and he did not shy away from acknowledging the role of manager Oli Marmol’s decisions in the outcome.
During a press availability on Friday, DeWitt Jr. emphasized that while the Cardinals’ struggles cannot be pinned on a single person, several tactical mistakes by Marmol factored into the team’s downfall.
Questionable In-Game Decisions
DeWitt pointed to bullpen management as a recurring issue, especially in late-game situations during the elimination series. “We had opportunities to close out games, but some of the pitching changes didn’t put us in the best position,” DeWitt said. “In October, every inning is magnified, and those choices matter.”
Missed Offensive Adjustments
The Cardinals’ lack of offensive production in key moments also drew criticism. DeWitt noted that Marmol failed to make timely lineup adjustments against opposing pitching. “We had bats on the bench that could have given us a spark. Those opportunities were missed,” he added.
Holding Players Accountable
While acknowledging the talent on the roster, DeWitt stressed that the manager bears responsibility for keeping the team sharp. “There were mental errors and lapses in focus that shouldn’t happen in the postseason. That reflects preparation and leadership,” he said.
Support, but With Expectations
Despite his criticism, DeWitt stopped short of indicating Marmol’s immediate dismissal. Instead, he described the elimination as a turning point. “Oli is young and capable, but mistakes at this level are costly. Going forward, we expect adjustments, accountability, and a return to Cardinals baseball,” DeWitt concluded.
The comments mark a rare moment of public critique from the Cardinals’ top executive, adding to speculation about Marmol’s long-term future. With fans frustrated and the franchise at a crossroads, the pressure on the dugout will be intense heading into the 2026 season.
About the Author
