Cardinals Decide to Keep All-Star Brendan Donovan Despite Trade Rumors
| October 19, 2025
As MLB’s offseason picks up, the St. Louis Cardinals are at the center of trade speculation, with many expecting big roster changes. Veterans like Nolan Arenado, Sonny Gray, and Willson Contreras are seen as possible trade candidates. However, much of the recent attention has turned to All-Star Brendan Donovan, whose breakout season has sparked widespread interest across the league.
Donovan’s Growing Value
Donovan’s ability to play multiple defensive positions at a high level, along with his leadership in the clubhouse, has made him an important figure in St. Louis. The Cardinals now face a key decision—whether to trade Donovan while his value is high or continue to build around him as part of their core.
Baseball insider Jon Heyman voiced doubt over the likelihood of a trade involving Donovan, stating, “I think that’s a rumor that’s going to go on forever and never happen. Donovan, I wouldn’t do it if I were them.” His comments reflect a broader belief that the Cardinals view Donovan as too valuable to let go.
A Wider Trade Picture
While Donovan’s situation is drawing attention, other young players—such as Lars Nootbaar, Nolan Gorman, Alec Burleson, and Jordan Walker—have also come up in trade discussions. However, the consensus appears to be that the team is leaning toward holding on to Donovan, due to both his recent performance and potential impact moving forward.
The Cardinals’ front office is entering a crucial period. Choosing to keep Donovan may signal an intent to rebuild around a mix of young talent and experienced leaders rather than starting a full overhaul.
Fan Response and What’s Ahead
Fans have largely reacted with surprise—and relief—to the idea that Donovan might stay in St. Louis. His bond with the fan base and significant on-field contributions make him a logical piece to retain as the team looks to re-establish itself as a contender.
As the offseason progresses, the Cardinals will need to carefully assess whether retaining Donovan strengthens their long-term strategy. For now, keeping him suggests the organization is focused on building a balanced and competitive roster for the future.
About the Author
