Why the Red Sox Should Sign Both Kyle Schwarber and Alex Bregman
After trading Rafael Devers and extending Roman Anthony on a team-friendly $130 million deal, the Boston Red Sox have financial flexibility this offseason—and they should use it aggressively.
Rather than making just one marquee signing, the Red Sox could make a bold statement by bringing in Alex Bregman and reuniting with Kyle Schwarber.
According to projections, Bregman could command a five-year, $160 million contract, while Schwarber might seek a four-year, $128 million deal. Combined, that’s nearly $288 million in new commitments—an amount well within reach for a big-market team like Boston, which has too often acted conservatively in recent years.
Trading Devers was not just a cost-cutting move; it was an opportunity to reallocate resources. The deal saved the organization roughly $254 million, meaning signing Bregman and Schwarber would still leave the payroll in a manageable position while reshaping the roster around a more balanced core.
Familiar Faces with Proven Impact
Bregman already has a strong rapport with manager Alex Cora, and his leadership, consistency, and postseason experience make him an ideal fit. During his tenure in Boston, he has shown reliable production, hitting .273/.360/.462 with 18 home runs and an .821 OPS, while earning an All-Star selection.
Schwarber’s case is equally compelling. During his stint with the Red Sox in 2021, he quickly became a clubhouse favorite, showcasing leadership and power. His offensive consistency since then has been remarkable—56 home runs in 2025, and 94 in the past two seasons. Few players match his power output or ability to energize a lineup.
Even Alex Cora has previously expressed intrigue about Schwarber’s future, hinting that Boston could pursue a reunion.
Raising the Ceiling for 2026 and Beyond
Boston’s young talent—led by Anthony—has laid a strong foundation. Adding veteran stars like Bregman and Schwarber would relieve pressure on the younger players while giving the Red Sox a legitimate chance to return to contention. Combined with a potential trade for another starting pitcher, these moves could transform Boston into a World Series-caliber team as soon as 2026.
For Chief Baseball Officer Craig Breslow, this offseason represents a defining moment. Winning over fans and re-establishing Boston as a powerhouse will require bold action—and there’s no clearer way to do that than by signing two proven stars the fanbase already admires.
Leave a Reply